Math and Science Book Reviews
- These are brief notes on an eclectic set of books--suitable for high-school and gifted middle-school students-- that I think will interest my friends and math / science teachers (the categories are not mutually exclusive). This list consists of books I happened to run across in my unsystematic search for good reads. None of them are textbooks, but almost all are useful for enrichment material. I have not hesitated to mention a few clinkers to avoid. Adult science and math aficionados will also enjoy most of them (you are an aficionado, I am a junkie).
Only abbreviated references are given (author, title) since with today's computers,
it is very easy to find the rest of the information--including the price if
the book is currently available. Try Amazon.com, for example, or your own library's
computer. I do not think year of publication is important in determining the
value of a book; many of the old or middle-age ones are unjustly forgotten in
the spate of new releases. The books reviewed here range from the middle 1800s
to manuscripts I've read in preprint and which are just coming out.
Faraday, Michael. The chemical history of a candle
Yes, THE Michael Faraday. With a preface by William Crookes (yes, that William
Crookes). Written in 1861, this book is as delightful today as it must have
been then. He gets a prodigious amount of basic science out of some relatively
simple and rather clear experiments, many of which are readily duplicated. Topics
such as the products and nature of combustion, that water is made of hydrogen
and oxygen, and many others are touched on and well-illuminated (by candlelight).
Boys, C.V. Soap Bubbles and the forces which mould them
Today's students may not topple with laughter when the experiment requires
the author to tip a candle so that "the falling grease will just fall on
the edge of the candlestick and splash on to the carpet" because our students
have not been taught, from an early age, that one must always hold a candle
upright and to never spill candle wax on the carpet. On the other hand, it is
at just this angle that the shadow of the base of the candlestick makes a parabola
on the wall. Even if not all the humor survives from 1902, the cleverness, directness,
and simplicity of the experiments and the wealth of science they uncover are
undimmed. A delightful book, scant in page count and easily digested.
Bitter, Francis. Magnets, The education of a physicist.
Bitter writes, "Let me tell you something of what I learned, and why it
fascinated me." And he does, with charm and at a level that youngsters
can follow. Bitter (after whom the magnetics lab at MIT is named) made many
fundamental discoveries about magnetism, but his career was varied. We read
of the earth's magnetic field, how he helped keep magnetic mines from blowing
up ships in World War II, and of the magnetism of the nucleus of the atom. This
is a small book, dated 1959, quickly read, but rich in personality and well-presented
science.
Casti, John. Five golden rules
A look at some major issues in modern mathematics. Only for the very talented
student who wants to strike out beyond the normal course matter, it is readable
because it mostly talks about some very exciting mathematics rather than actually
having the math there. Covers the minimax theorem of game-theory fame, the Brouwer
fixed-point theorem (topology), and the Halting problem, among other topics.
Also good for teachers who want a feel for some major mathematical developments
of the 20th century, in case some bright kid asks.
Dewdney, A.K. 200% of nothing
John Allen Paulos popularized the term "innumeracy" and a number
of books have followed showing the consequences of not understanding basic mathematics
(including Paulos's own "A mathematician reads the newspaper"). This
is the best and most readable of those I've seen. A math-grokking sixth-grader
will find little over her head here. Especially good for parents. Students who
like to critique what they see and read will get lots of ammo here, ammo especially
useful for shooting down specious advertising claims.
Dewdney, A.K. Yes, we have no neutrons
One of the best ways to get to understand something is to see how it fails.
In solving problems we look for edge conditions, and we only learn how strong
a toothpick is by breaking a few. Dewdney helps us understand sound science
by looking at broken science; not confusion but cold fusion; not fraud but Freud.
He tells the tales well, the book is entertaining, and the overall picture of
science as a self-correcting enterprise is well presented. "Yes, we have
no neutrons" is a good book to read alongside of all those stories where
the end result is a Nobel prize, rather than an ignoble footnote. Students will
love the way the good guys trip up the bad guys.
Stein, Sherman. Strength in Numbers
A very good book on various empowering mathematical topics. The book strays
a bit much into questions of pedagogy for the young student, but there are many
chapters that, taken by themselves, make great short readings. The book is well-written,
requiring no math background beyond the most elementary of algebra and some
comfort with exponents, and perhaps a bit more than that toward the end of the
book (but, of course, you are going to use only selected chapters). A few elementary
proofs are presented very clearly, and their impact is explained. My favorite
part is where Stein shows that lots of great art and the pyramids etc. were
not based on the golden ratio, as is so often claimed. I argued that very point
in class once to a teacher who believed otherwise, and who couldn't follow my
statistical demonstration. If only I'd had this book then. Small oops: the St.
Louis arch is not a catenary.
Peterson, Ivars. The jungles of randomness
A set of loosely connected essays on various mathematical (and sometimes non-mathematical)
topics that is simple in its approach and comprehensible in its treatment of
randomness, chaos, gambling, and the like. By chance (so to speak), the preprint
of this book arrived when I was working with two seventh-graders building electronic
oscillators. However, the oscillators tended to lock onto certain relative frequency
pairs. The book's chapter on coupled oscillators, whether mechanical, electronic,
or even thousands of fireflies in the jungle, was just the explanation they
needed.
Trefil, James. A scientist at the seashore
Covering tides and many other littoral phenomena, both physical and biological,
the book will help the young reader better understand waves, how sailboats work,
and other topics about where solids and liquids meet on our planet. Most of
the book is fine, unfortunately, chapter 11 is very wrong: Trefil just does
not understand lift and even gets the direction a ball turns due to its spin
wrong (complete with an explanation of why it has to be the way he says it is!).
I look forward to having some students read this chapter and then try to explain
why a spinning ball (a beachball makes the effects clearly visible in class)
turns the "wrong" way. This chapter is valuable as an object lesson
that you can't believe everything you read in books, you've got to keep a scientist's
skeptical eye open at all times.
McMahon, Thomas and Bonner, Tyler. On size and life
Reminiscent of the classic "On growth and form" by D'arcy Thompson
(still very much worth reading!) but moving from biology (of which there's still
lots) into other realms, this well-illustrated book is a fascinating read. The
effects of size on antelope, saxophone, bridge, dragonfly, and clock are all
discussed. Yes, a very few differential equations are shown, but the exposition
does not depend on your understanding them. After all, this is a Scientific
American book, and very few Americans, scientific or otherwise, get along with
equations, differential or otherwise. So tell your students to skip the rare
harder math, follow the easy math, understand the graphs, and look at the pretty
pictures.
Sagan, Carl. The demon-haunted world
I got a catalog in the mail that advertised a silver bracelet that can "eliminate
harmful positive ions and guide helpful negative ions into your body" as
well as "keeping you safe from dangerous electromagnetic fields (EMF)".
A science fair project at a school for the gifted began, "Since homeopathy
is a precise science..." Aside from daily injections of articles from the
Skeptical Inquirer, few readings are as likely to be as helpful to weeding the
mind of the sprouts of superstition as this one. Sagan takes a temperate tone
and a moderate stance when it comes to religious issues, the book is not likely
to offend any but the most extreme fundamentalists. "The demon-haunted
world" is a long book, but most of the chapters can be read independently.
The chapter "The fine art of baloney detection" is especially useful
for its list of ways people argue illogically.
Gonick, L. and Huffman, A. The cartoon guide to physics
Physics presented with a sugar coating. Some subjects are treated more deeply
(or, should I say, more shallowly) than others, but all are treated with care
and accuracy. Not a text, but a fine supplement. Who knows, it might reach someone
that more conventional approaches don't. And for the student who likes physics,
or the adult who wants to brush up on basic terms and principles, it makes a
fine, quick overview. And it's fun (which is what the authors were trying for).
Guy, Richard and Woodrow, Robert, editors. The lighter side of mathematics
For the very advanced student or adult who knows how to work through a math
book, this one looks into a few interesting topics in some depth. I found it
was not as light as its title hinted. Nonetheless, some of the games presented
can be profitably studied (or at least enjoyed) by fifth-graders and up, and
the analyses of Escher's tessellations are accessible. And even where the proofs
at the ends of articles may be difficult and the terminology esoteric, the problem
statements are often elementary and can be happily explored by kids. If nothing
else, a math teacher will be able to extract ideas useful for class and individual
enrichment.
Blatner, David. The Joy of Pi
Stories and lore of pi. There are better books on the subject, but this one
is small, colorful, and informal. And it does tell a few tales (some from non-Western
mathematics and some of which it accurately labels as apocryphal) that are not
well known. The back of the book tells it like it is, "breezy narratives
tell the history of pi and the quirky stories of those obsessed with it."
[Available December 1997]
Pullum, Geoffrey. The great Eskimo vocabulary hoax
Why do I not capitalize the important words in the book titles in this list?
Read this book. This book is very, very funny. It is also quite educational
about the nature of language, and very sane. It would probably be appreciated
best by adults, since the humor is sophisticated (not ribald). I wish it had
been three times as long. At least. The essay on the Eskimo vocabulary hoax
is a good example of why you should go to primary sources, recommended for middle
school and up. The chapters, originally published as columns in a linguistics
journal, are quite independent, and the teacher can pick and choose.
Dupre, Lyn. Bugs in writing
How often does a book come along that has you laughing out loud as it improves
your writing, especially of technical and scientific material. How often does
a book on writing come out aimed at scientists, mathematicians and computer
specialists in the first place? How often does a book on grammar keep you turning
the pages from pleasure? Never, you say? Then get this one. It is organized
into small sections, very useful for the teacher, since the sections can be
read as needed to help cure specific bad writing habits. Indeed, Dupre recommends
you use the book this way. Splendid.
Bruce, Colin. The strange case of Mrs. Hudson's cat
Surprisingly good as a pastiche of the Canon; Holmes, Watson, Mycroft and the
usual gang explore some "science mysteries" in a readable account.
It is not a bad way to tackle a bit of classical physics, and a pretty good
way to examine a few of the paradoxes of quantum mechanics and special relativity.
Totally devoid of mathematics, it is an easily read, thought-provoking book.
The student should, however, be familiar with Holmes's modus operandi from having
read Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's original. If the student is already a Holmes fan,
this is a natural.
Aldersey-Williams, Hugh. The most beautiful molecule
An extremely well-written and engaging account of the discovery of C60, buckminsterfullerene,
the soccer-ball-shaped molecule consisting of 60 carbon atoms. The book looks
at the discovery, the personalities (without being sensational, a welcome change
from the usual), the molecule, the science, the scientific milieu, and the ensuing
technology. Occasionally, toward the end of the book, the author slips and expects
more background than a school-age reader might usually have, but for most of
the book everything is introduced and explained properly before it is used.
Hard to put down once you've started. Not only good science, but a fine book
per se. As a writer, I'm almost jealous.
Wilson, Edward. Naturalist
Edward Wilson's autobiography. Wilson's fabulous work on ants is well-known
and he has two Pulitzer prizes. Given that background, one would expect a great
autobiography and here it is. Very non-technical and full of youthful adventure
and the overcoming of adversity, it will attract the non-science-oriented student
as well as the budding entomologist.
Huxley, Thomas. On a piece of chalk (Scribners, 1967)
I give some information on the edition because it is a handsome book that is
a pleasure in itself. Huxley, Darwin's contemporary and most prominent defender,
draws his piece of chalk across the blackboard of geologic history to explain
the origins of the chalk itself (as the skeletons of uncounted billions of Foraminifera)
and to defend the then-nascent theory of natural selection. The defense is based
on the physical evidence found in the chalk beds that form the famous white
cliffs of Dover. The writing is clear and direct. This is a very accessible
book, and a delight.
Weaver, Jefferson. The world of physics
This three-volume set advertises itself accurately as "a small library
of the literature of physics from antiquity to the present". From the pre-Socratic
Greeks to Einstein and beyond, and not (for once) neglecting non-Western sources,
this well-selected collection should be available to every science class, and
is a worthy candidate for a school library. I found it fun to read: There were
brief gems, many by famous scientists about their own work, I had never read--and
should have.
Ord-Hume, A.W.J.G. Perpetual motion, the history of an obsession
The fun part here is when students try to figure out why the many gadgets illustrated
didn't work--or try to invent perpetual motion machines of their own. A nice
segue into the conservation of energy, friction, entropy, and such. Mr. Ord-Hume
is a bit shaky on his physics here and there even if he comes out on the right
side of the perpetual motion issue.
Harré, Rom. Great scientific experiments
From Aristotle's observation of the embryology of the chick, to Gibson on perception,
to Thompson's discovery of the electron, 20 historically important experiments
are described. This is a very good introduction to the importance of experiment
in science. It reads well and is suitable for middle-school students and up.
As with so many of these books, I found it enjoyable adult reading.
Gardner, Martin.
All of his books on mathematics are winners. I need say no more, he is a classic.
OK, some titles from my shelves: Gotcha!, The unexpected hanging, Mathematical
magic show, The magic numbers of Dr. Matrix, Curious problems and puzzles, Time
travel and other mathematical bewilderments, ...
Barrow, John. Pi in the sky
I thought this would be a book about pi, but it is a rambling account of math,
linguistics, and philosophy. Most of its contents have been done better elsewhere.
Skip it.
Maor, Eli. e, the story of a number
This is a book on the base of the natural logarithms, e. e permeates mathematics
and pops up in all kinds of practical settings, nearly as often as does pi.
More for teachers than their students, I found it useful as a source of answers
when my eighth-grade son began to ask serious questions about e. Maor is always
worth reading on the origins and history of mathematics. This book was hard
to find because the computer systems in the stores couldn't deal with a one-letter
key word!
Thomas, Lewis. The lives of a cell
Lewis Thomas is one of our supreme stylists in science writing. And this book
is among his finest. Read it as either science or literature, take your pick.
"The lives of a cell" is a collection of independent essays, mostly
related to biology and medicine: It can be parceled out to worthy students as
if it were a box of bon-bons. If you haven't read this book yet yourself, today
is as good a time as any to start it.
Bascom, Willard. Waves and beaches
Not intended for children, but not too difficult for the high school student,
the treatment of the physics of water waves and beaches is surprisingly comprehensive
and fascinating, with no advanced math. Any surfer will appreciate its description
of where and how to get half-mile rides, and will gather on the way, a good
understanding of wave motion. The title gives scant information on the breadth
of the topics covered, including the stability of boats (kids will love the
chapter "Why ships sink"), how to get more energy from salt domes
than from the oil deposits that underlay them, and the amazing effects of seiches.
Another very enjoyable book!
Bascom, Willard. The crest of the wave
Tales from the sea, me mateys. As exciting as anything experienced by Long
John Silver or Captains Bligh and Queeg, a master oceanographer writes, and
writes well, of his adventures seeking the exotic phenomena of the sea. Bascom
tangles with torpedoes, undersea mining, pollution of the seas, monster waves,
and--of course--sunken treasure. Completely non-technical, yet full of enticing
facts and observations. I was tempted to stop writing these capsule reviews
and just curl up with this book, again.
Epstein, Lewis Carroll. Relativity visualized
The best book I've seen to explain relativity to the young scientist. Careful,
accurate, and clear, with an occasional problem to help the reader see if her
thinking is on the right track. The math is limited to elementary algebra (with
a smidgen of calculus in a note to teachers). Even if you don't have to do much
math, you do have to think, and think carefully. I found that I had mislearned
a commonly misunderstood point about relativity (I'll bet it's not the only
one) and the books explanation made it clear why I was wrong. It is one of my
son's favorite books, and has been since his clever mother got it for him when
he was in sixth grade.
Lightman, Alan. Time travel & papa Joe's pipe
The opening essay on time travel is thin and soppy. And he goes on in this
vein. Nice title.
Fadiman, Clifton. Fantasia mathematica
The only work of fiction in this list, it is a nearly-forgotten compilation
of some fine short stories with mathematical themes. When I read this as a youngster
it triggered my mathematical imagination, and it did the same for kids I have
shown it to since. The math concepts underlying the stories are often solid,
but always entertaining. Start with the story "A subway named Moebius".
There's Heinlein's classic "--And he built a crooked house", some
poetical fripperies at the end, and much more. Highly recommended.
Bell, E.T. Men of mathematics
The title alone tells you it's dated, and better scholarship (see Stein, Strength
in Numbers, for some corrections) has undermined a few of the more glamorous
incidents. But all in all it is one of the most readable set of short biographies
of mathematicians and their work. And if it makes the lives and exploits of
mathematicians sound a bit more exciting than they were, well...
Greenstein, George. Portraits of Discovery
A few selected biographies of an unusual choice of subjects, which is what
makes the book work. Included are Annie Jump Cannon and Cecilia Payne-Gaposchkin,
astronomers at the last turn-of-the-century; Margaret Geller and John Huchra,
astronomers currently; Ludwig Boltzmann; Homi Bhabha and the science of India;
and so forth. Too often Greenstein injects his own comments explicitly into
the book, and he too often states that some theory or fact is fascinating instead
of making it fascinating for the reader; I found the book's style to be annoying
at times. Your mileage may vary. On the other hand, having 3 female subjects
out of 10 is a great batting average, and might commend this book to the young
girl on her way to a love of science.
Paulos, John Allen. A mathematician reads the newspaper
The author of "Innumeracy" takes on its effects in the daily press
and the other mass media, to good effect. Books like this (and another on this
list, Dewdney's "200% of nothing") are true must-reads if we are to
inoculate our students against the diarrhea of bad statistics and incomplete
numerical facts that contaminate the information fed to us each day.
Steinhaus, H. Mathematical snapshots
Another book that inspired the pre-college me, it has been reprinted since
I was a lad. "Mathematical snapshots" is a collection of interesting
illustrations that illuminate mathematical topics. And what a range of topics!
The way mud cracks, how to balance a broom without looking, polyhedra, bubbles,
music, chess, tilings, growth of trees (the wooden kind), and on and on. Plenty
of ideas for hands-on projects, things to build and touch, and lots of connections
between unlikely mathematical partners. It's better than I remembered it. A
gem.
Gribbin, John. In search of Schrodinger's cat
When I read this book years ago, it left a strange, shadowed impression. So
I reread all of it for this brief review. What a pleasant surprise: It contains
the clearest account of the rise and nature of quantum theory (up to but not
including quantum electrodynamics (QED)) that I have seen. For the student or
adult who wants to get a feel for the beast (without the math), this book would
be hard to better. I was wondering why I had put the book into the "dubious"
category... until I got to chapter 11. My remembered distaste was clearly a
result of the last few chapters in which Everett's parallel universe interpretation
of quantum mechanics is enthusiastically discussed. After 234 pages of correctly
emphasizing that one thing we have learned from quantum theory is to not make
scientific claims about what cannot be observed, we have an explosion of philosophizing
about parallel universes that, even in principle, cannot be observed. This finally
leads him to the benighted anthropic principle. An epilog weakly discusses the
development of QED and a bit beyond. This sad end does not diminish the value
of the first 10 chapters.
|