|
The Dismal State of Computer Curricula
The following quote was run Wednesday, March 19, 2003 in NewScan
Daily, an online news service. It originally was part of a white paper on the use of computers in schools that Jef prepared for the Nueva school in Hillsborough, California:
There are many issues involved in designing a computer curriculum. I find the
amount of trivia that must be mastered by each student (in fact, by each of
us) in order to use a computer to be obscenely huge. Students become proud that
they know where in the morass of menus and dialog boxes a certain control is
to be found. They should be angry that they had to spend time learning the obscure,
and that others are encumbered by having to deal with such issues. We should
be teaching them to be sensitive to the havoc bad design wreaks on us. We teach
history, but also add a moral component and do not hesitate to condemn racial
and ethnic prejudice, the predation of dictators, and the use of force for solving
differences. We teach science, and do not omit mentioning the important need
to think about the consequences of new discoveries, and our responsibility to
see that they are used ethically. When we teach "adding menu items, buttons,
text input fields", we are only helping students add to the dismal state of
computer use. Perhaps we should call it user abuse. We can try to justify this
amoral stance by saying that we are teaching useful skills, but I am not convinced.
We teach civility in daily personal interaction, we must teach it in computer
interaction as well. (Jef Raskin)
|